Star Wars Rogue One - CGI Tarkin Explained

star warsrogue onestar wars rogue onerogue one a star wars storyrogue one cgirogue one tarkinrogue one leiarogue one tarkin cgirogue one leia cgitarkin peter cushinggeorge lucaspeter cushingcarrie fisher rogue oneguy henry rogue onewho played tarkin in rogue onewho played leia in rogue onerogue one cameosrogue one cgi explainedrogue one visual effects

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story CGI revealed! Rogue One featured cameos from characters in Star Wars A New Hope, including Grand Moff Tarkin (the late Peter Cushing) and another surprise character, with CGI and visual effects from George Lucas' company Industrial Light & Magic.

Spoilers below!

Rogue One ends with the reveal of Princess Leia (Carrie Fisher) as she appeared in the original Star Wars in 1977. How did Rogue One pull off this effect? And how did the movie feature Tarkin in several scenes after Peter Cushing died in 1994? Erik Voss explains the advanced visual effects techniques used by John Knoll of Industrial Light & Magic, combining stand-in actors, archive footage, and motion capture to re-create a character on screen. How intensive is this process exactly, and what ethical questions does it present?



Kenny Smith
Matthew Salvas
Kevin Chauhan
Pony Stark
Daniel Hopkins
Eric Oliver
Lucious Barnes
Chris Cole

Executive Producer: Jeben Berg
Producer: Ted Marsden
Host: Erik Voss (@eavoss)
Writer: Erik Voss (@eavoss)
Post Production Supervisor: Ericson Just (@justericson)
Editor: Ericson Just (@justericson), Ted Marsden
Creative Director: Filup Molina (@fimo)

the cgi wasn't ready for this standin stuff.... not, one, bit
Manny V
id watch a hole movie with every like that i was trippin
Martin Anthonyo
so glad they past the uncanny valley
CGI Tarkin is far better done than CGI Leia. Sure CGI Tarkin looks kind of like a wax figure, but his facial expressions are nuanced and life-like, as opposed to Leia, who looks like a dead-eyed character from a poorly animated video game cut scene. Hell, even recent video games like Uncharted 4 have better facial animation than Leia. Maybe they ran out of budget.
I still feel that we are not quite there when attempting to model a face via cgi. Something always seems off in terms of the movement of the face or gloss of the skin which makes it look like it belongs more in a video game than a film in my opinion.
Survivor of Alderaan
Another annoying narrator. This one reminds me of Russel Crowe.
Taika 92
Ioi Leilani
I had a serious uncanny valley moment when I saw CGI Leia. Very eerie.
Sir Monkeys
I honestly didn't know tarkin was cgi
Thomas Cox
I dont think the tarkin in revenge of the sith is horrible I think its brilliant.
Little Bro Troy Production
I subscribed
Andrew Chapman
4:24 LMAO!
Don't make fun of Jar-Jar! He originally supposed to be a Sith Lord
Lisa Adler
I really hope GTA VI characters look this good
Arzamas -16
Sorry, but the CG Leia looked absolutely terrible. And the xwing pilots were not CG. Those were unused clips from ANH.
I personally was unimpressed with the Facial CGI for Tarkin and Leia.
6:21 grandma tarkin
Craig Stanley
I enjoyed the cgi,the limits are endless.
Blake Hunter
Honestly when I first saw rogue one I didn't even notice at first that Tarkin was CGI I thought it was maybe an actor with makeup or something. Props to the cgi people who pulled that one off.
And Breathe..
Michael Marshall
A lot of work and money went into recreating these characters, but unfortunately the final effect wasn't convincing enough. For it to work, it needs to be flawless - and it wasn't. I liked the film, but would have preferred it without this.
ill Eez
Watched this in 4DX and it was awesome - Pure action start to finish!

...Vaders saber scene was the cherry on top of the icing on the cake!
KAMEK pictures
I don't understand that some people hated the CGI tarkin... I thought he looked great. Legolas in the Hobbit looked like a CGI character!
Terrible movie... good CGI!?!? Tarkin is the main reason I walked out.. too many cut scenes. No characters to get emotionally attached to.
Katharine Wade
Thing is tho, Tarking didn't look 100% real, but a lot of Star Wars don't look 100% real, but its such a great story, that it really didn't matter to me,
Kal-El Kent
Sorry but CGI for me is like watching a cartoon, I like it but it's Roger Rabbit, humans mixed with cartoons on film, till that day comes when I cannot tell the difference which I don't think will ever come, I am not a fan of resurrecting actors using CGI
Surprisingly good? Someone has low standards...
I can't believe that this is really the best CGI can do at the moment. I was really deeply disappointed watching this in the cinema.
crazy Chicken1
Tarkin looks like a character from a video game with really good graphics
Tom Dotson
i thought the cgi was horrible
CGI wasn't good actually. It was average.
Jacob Nelson
No... it was not impressive. it was bad... bad, bad,bad. His body was fidgety and awkward and I was uncomfortable not impressed.
Jeff Wulf
I thought the CGI was horrific.
Marcus Jacob (TheGidJac)
Leia wasn't CGI she was played by an actress who looked like her. I looked in the credits.
Hans Wurst
the computer tarkin looks like crap .... :/
Martin Jamieson
I get why they made Leia CGI (though it didn't look fantastic), and honestly didn't even notice the pilots were CGi... but they re-cast Mon Mothma, why not just get someone else to play Tarkin? The film wouldn't have lost anything, but the weird Tin Tin looking puppet effect just made the Tarkin scenes completely glaring examples of 'suspension of disbelief'. He was too major a role in the movie for going with CGI.
Louis Smets
Pregnancy jacket wing normally stock juice pilot hard metaphor initiate
Archimedes 515
Why did the have to edit in Carrie fisher when the film released on the tenth of December and she died on the 27th
10 more years...CGI will bring anyone back to the silver screen..or 32k ;)
Galactic Ninetails
It's felicity jones daughter playing as princess leia
Christopher Caleb
James West
There were people crying in the cinema I saw Rogue One in when young Carrie came on because it was a day or so after she died :(
Wow...imagine the kind of scam people with access to this technology could actually pull out on the public...
I thought Tarkin looked more convincing than Leia to be honest.
Cronix RBLX
Best Star Wars movie ever.
Nunovya Biznez
The amount of people who are tweaking and having a hissy insisting that Leia should not be created in future movies is a shame.
Nicholas Stafford
this looks aweful
Esork Gonzalez
I've got to admit, the CGI actually looked convincing to a lot of people, and I must have been one of those who knew they were CGI, but I didn't mind, as long as it's close to realistic, I'm cool with it.
Tarkin in RotS didn't look wierd, he was supposed to be a younger Tarkin....
Little did they know 9 days after this was uploaded, Carrie Fisher would die. :'(
Related Videos
Thumbnail: The creation of Princess Leia, Grand Moff Tarkin in "Rogue One"
Thumbnail: Star Wars Rogue One ALL Easter Eggs & References (FULL MOVIE)
Thumbnail: How 'Rogue One' Recreated Grand Moff Tarkin | Design FX | WIRED
Thumbnail: Rogue One A Star Wars Story Darth Vader Scenes Explained, Vader’s Castle/Cloaked Figure
Thumbnail: Logan FULL BREAKDOWN - Visual Analysis & Things You Missed
Thumbnail: How Rogue One Created Princess Leia, Grand Moff Tarkin
Thumbnail: Rogue One Moments Only True Fans Understood
Thumbnail: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story - Deleted Scenes [HD]
Thumbnail: The Ending Of Rogue One Explained
Thumbnail: CGI GRAND MOFF TARKIN - Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
Thumbnail: Grand Moff Tarkin Scenes - Star Wars A New Hope
Thumbnail: Alderaan's Destruction - A New Hope [1080p HD]
Thumbnail: 10 Amazing Deleted Movie Scenes ALL Star Wars Fans Must See (Force Awakens, Rogue One)
Thumbnail: Rogue one Spoiler Leia Tarkin CGI Compared to Episode 4 and Episode 3
Thumbnail: 10 Star Wars Mysteries That Were Never Answered
Thumbnail: Star Wars News - Lucasfilm Confirms Carrie Fisher CGI Replacement NOT HAPPENING
Thumbnail: Rogue One: 21 Easter Eggs You Need to Know (Spoilers)
Thumbnail: Peter Cushing on playing Grand Moff Tarkin on carpet slippers in STAR WARS - EPISODE IV: A NEW HOPE
Thumbnail: Rogue One Stars Answer the Web's Most Searched Questions | WIRED
Thumbnail: Rogue One: Behind the Scenes | Star Wars 2016
Thumbnail: Rogue One a Star Wars Story DARTH VADER Scenes Explained! MAJOR SPOILERS!!
Thumbnail: 10 Bloopers In Star Wars Movies You May Have Missed
Thumbnail: 10 Star Wars Mysteries That Have Never Been Solved
Thumbnail: Star Wars Rogue One NEW TIMELINE - Changes to A New Hope!
Thumbnail: Rogue One - THE MYSTERY OF DARTH VADER'S CASTLE! (Rogue One A Star Wars Story Explained)
Thumbnail: Rogue One Star Wars Easter Eggs
Thumbnail: Star Wars Rogue One - ALTERNATE ENDING THEORY (Deleted Scenes from Trailers)
Thumbnail: How Star Wars Rogue One Should Have Ended
Thumbnail: Star Wars Anthology Rogue One Brings Back Grand Moff Tarkin?
Thumbnail: Did Tarkin Know Darth Vader's True Identity?
Thumbnail: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story - CGI Tarkin and Leia Organa
Thumbnail: 10 Star Wars Changes That Were Completely Justified
Thumbnail: Why Does Darth Vader Take Orders From Grand Moff Tarkin in A New Hope - Star Wars Explained
Thumbnail: How Star Wars Should Have Ended (Special Edition)
Thumbnail: 10 Star Wars Fan Theories That Will Blow Your Mind
Thumbnail: Rogue One Director Explains Why They Brought Back Tarkin Using CGI
Thumbnail: Rogue One - CGI Tarkin footage High Quality (from Making of/trailers)
Thumbnail: Star Wars Force Awakens ALL Easter Eggs & References ( FULL MOVIE )
Thumbnail: ROGUE ONE: A STAR WARS STORY All Easter Eggs & References
Thumbnail: Rogue One Cast & Director Reveal What They Stole From Set
Thumbnail: Star Wars Rogue One Darth Vader WTF Scenes Explained
Thumbnail: Star Wars ROGUE ONE Easter Eggs, References, and Cameos Explained
Thumbnail: #CreateCourage - Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
Thumbnail: Did Rogue One Tease Snoke's Origin?
Thumbnail: Comparing The Voices - Grand Moff Tarkin
Thumbnail: Star Wars Rogue One TOP 20 Easter Eggs
Thumbnail: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story - Spoiler Review
Thumbnail: The Craziest Star Wars Interviews You’ve Never Seen! (Until Now!)
Thumbnail: 5 ROGUE ONE Easter Eggs You May Have Missed - Star Wars: "ROGUE ONE" Movie
Thumbnail: Top 10 Worst Reasons You Liked Rogue One