This song initially appears like other musical numbers in the show, with Lucifer (Tom Ellis) sitting at his piano and playing this morose Chris Isaak cover. However, God (Dennis Haysbert) is also present and is coaxing Lucifer into singing about his feelings for Chloe (Lauren German) and his inability to embrace them.

The world was on fire
And no one could save me but you
It's strange what desire
Will make foolish people do
I never dreamed that I'd meet somebody like you
And I never dreamed that I'd lose somebody like you

What a wicked game to play
To make me feel this way
What a wicked thing to do
To let me dream of you
What a wicked thing to say
You never felt this way
What a wicked thing to do
To make me dream of you

No, I wanna fall in love
No, I wanna fall in love
No, I wanna fall in love
With you